ForumOnline-Shop

Author Topic: full time headgear editorial from 1971  (Read 4967 times)

Offline pesp

  • Gold Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 261
full time headgear editorial from 1971
« on: 15. April 2012, 18:29:06 PM »
https://dereferer.me/?https://dereferer.me/?http://www.jco-online.com/archive/article-view.aspx?year=1971&month=06&articlenum=301

This is an editorial from the Journal of Clinical Orthodontics in 1971.  Sadly, my orthodontist at the time believed this to be a great idea and signed on, even though only a few orthodontist even tried this.  He was able to convince my parents it was a great idea.  I was in high school at the time and I tried to tell them it was a bad idea.  They made me wear it anyway.

I did not end up wearing it to school, but had to wear it the rest of the time. That included immediately after school every day, all day all weekend, all day on holidays and vacations.  Problem was I was one of the only ones who actually wore it that much.  I hated every minute of it.  And it certainly did not help the high school social life.  That idiocy went on for over two years.

When I read this the other day all I could think of was, besides all of the miserable memories, from a sales point, history has shown how badly this idea flopped. But at the time this editor and my orthodontist really thought this was going to happen and I got stuck with their bad idea.

Offline DemBones

  • Gold Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 157
Re: full time headgear editorial from 1971
« Reply #1 on: 16. April 2012, 11:14:22 AM »
I’ve spoken to many orthodontists, and all of them agree that as a purely technical device, 24-hour headgear wear is simply the best way to treat the common Class-II overbite.  Strap ‘em in, 24 hours a day, a few months later, perfect smile.  My orthodontist at the time of my 1st treatment also was of this school – “wear it as much as possible.  Wear it always”.  At the time I was so unhappy with my physical appearance, 24 hour headgear-wear to get me sorted out seemed like a small price to pay. 

Little did I know...   I hardly ever wore it after the first few months, and “hardly ever” turned to “never”.  This resulted in my having braces – 1st time round - for 5 years as opposed to the projected 2. 

Headgear is a great way to achieve results, but the fact is, its a great way TECHNICALLY.  Its a really crappy way practically, because all fetishies aside, wearing headgear is actually quite crap and downright unpleasant.  This is where this marvellous treatment breaks down, its a really horrible way to spend 2 years of your life.  Newer techniques, like surgeries, do the same job in a fraction of the time with 4-6 weeks of extreme discomfort requiring zero patient compliance as opposed to 2 years of socially awkward and protracted treatment that requires a lot of patient cooperation. 

Headgear, great tool that it is, is simply just not a viable option anymore, and as we have seen, is only used in extreme cases.